MD5 collisions

Thursday 19 August 2004

Looks like the venerable MD5 cryptographic hash has developed a crack: A real MD5 collision. A team has published two different input streams which hash to the same MD5 value. Of course, because of the pigeonhole principle, everyone knew this had to happen. But no one had ever found a pair before.

Now that they have, researchers will be working on the question of whether it is feasible to compute, for any given input stream, a different stream with the same hash. If that happens, then MD5 is useless cryptographically, and a lot of infrastructure will have to be thrown out, but not before a bunch of bad stuff (like theft and fraud) happens.

Mark Pilgrim provides this Python program to demonstrate:

# see

a = "\xd1\x31\xdd\x02\xc5\xe6\xee\xc4\x69\x3d\x9a\x06\x98\xaf\xf9\x5c" \
    "\x2f\xca\xb5\x87\x12\x46\x7e\xab\x40\x04\x58\x3e\xb8\xfb\x7f\x89" \
    "\x55\xad\x34\x06\x09\xf4\xb3\x02\x83\xe4\x88\x83\x25\x71\x41\x5a" \
    "\x08\x51\x25\xe8\xf7\xcd\xc9\x9f\xd9\x1d\xbd\xf2\x80\x37\x3c\x5b" \
    "\xd8\x82\x3e\x31\x56\x34\x8f\x5b\xae\x6d\xac\xd4\x36\xc9\x19\xc6" \
    "\xdd\x53\xe2\xb4\x87\xda\x03\xfd\x02\x39\x63\x06\xd2\x48\xcd\xa0" \
    "\xe9\x9f\x33\x42\x0f\x57\x7e\xe8\xce\x54\xb6\x70\x80\xa8\x0d\x1e" \

b = "\xd1\x31\xdd\x02\xc5\xe6\xee\xc4\x69\x3d\x9a\x06\x98\xaf\xf9\x5c" \
    "\x2f\xca\xb5\x07\x12\x46\x7e\xab\x40\x04\x58\x3e\xb8\xfb\x7f\x89" \
    "\x55\xad\x34\x06\x09\xf4\xb3\x02\x83\xe4\x88\x83\x25\xf1\x41\x5a" \
    "\x08\x51\x25\xe8\xf7\xcd\xc9\x9f\xd9\x1d\xbd\x72\x80\x37\x3c\x5b" \
    "\xd8\x82\x3e\x31\x56\x34\x8f\x5b\xae\x6d\xac\xd4\x36\xc9\x19\xc6" \
    "\xdd\x53\xe2\x34\x87\xda\x03\xfd\x02\x39\x63\x06\xd2\x48\xcd\xa0" \
    "\xe9\x9f\x33\x42\x0f\x57\x7e\xe8\xce\x54\xb6\x70\x80\x28\x0d\x1e" \

print a == b

from md5 import md5
print md5(a).hexdigest() == md5(b).hexdigest()

Running it prints:



Add a comment:

Ignore this:
Leave this empty:
Name is required. Either email or web are required. Email won't be displayed and I won't spam you. Your web site won't be indexed by search engines.
Don't put anything here:
Leave this empty:
Comment text is Markdown.